Author Richard Dinnick has had one hit with me so far - Paradoxicide - but neither of his Hartnell stories (the other being A Star is Born,
which I reviewed a long time ago) have impressed. I have no real
problems with the acting and production, but this audio was still quite a
disappointment - worth my time, but not one I will be returning to
soon.
The extras are fairly typical fare, composed of enjoyable and disposable
chat with various participants; but one thing interested me in
particular. I had thought during the story - or episode 2, at least -
that what happened to Grigori would have fitted better with Nostradamus;
and sure enough, we find that it was originally written for him! A main
range story due to be released around the same time was using the
French prognosticator, and that gazumped the Companion Chronicle. A
rewrite followed. This surprised me because I thought the Russian
setting was the best thing about this story - perhaps Dinnick is an
author who works best under pressure! By coincidence I've since heard
that main range story, which was quite interesting - not an absolute
favourite, but better than The Wanderer.
I am trying to figure out what I can do with my marathon at the moment: I am not managing to get any momentum going, so something
needs to change. From next weekend I will probably be away from the
Internet for almost a fortnight, so I will have an opportunity for a bit
of a ponder - in between doing various exciting things that I shall say
a little about when I get back. At the moment my best thinking is that I
should write the conclusion to Iananbarbara's run (since everything I
am doing is a timeslip anyway) and dive into the next section, which
opens with one of my all-time favourite TV serials, and that might get
my enthusiasm going again. We'll see...
Published:
Date: April 2012
ISBN: 1-84435-621-8
Rating:
3.5/10.
Next Time:
Who knows?
Wednesday, 12 February 2014
Sunday, 9 February 2014
CC6.10b The Scorpion Men
Oh dear. I've been struggling with this marathon, and having to write a
negative review always applies the brakes to my (already stuttering)
momentum. I've been putting off reviewing the second episode of The Wanderer for weeks; time to bite the bullet. Still, this is going to be short one.
First, then, to tie up a couple of loose ends from last time. I was right about Grigori, which tends to make me feel good unless it's meant to be a mystery and is too obvious, which isn't true in this case. That's a plus. However, I also said that - as the first pseudohistorical drama I've covered - this needed to have a good alien plot. This one is bog-standard.
(An aside: I have reviewed a Hartnell pseudohistorical in this marathon, but it was a short story. For some reason I hold those to a different standard.)
The alien plot, as I say, is generic, and this puts pressure on the aliens themselves to provide interest. They threaten, they bluster, they kill... and that's it. No real character tics that we haven't seen many times before. They are admittedly visually impressive (and wouldn't have worked at all on TV, which isn't a complaint), but this is not enough. And the final solution to combating the menace is all rather "wha? where did that come from?", bringing up thoughts about how geology doesn't work like that - an inappropriate complaint for a Doctor Who story, but the fact that it came up is a red flag. Basically, this part of the episode falls very flat - and it is the main part.
What about the rest of the story? In terms of action it felt like running back and forth between the same two places, so not much to work with there. The business with Grigori is handled okay - Tim Chipping's performance is suitably mad, and the resolution was quite coolly crazy (in a 1964-ish way) - but the manner in which the potential opportunity to return Iananbarbara home was short-circuited felt clumsy. It wasn't even really necessary to hold out this promise in the first place! Grigori's situation could have been resolved by judicious use of the Fast Return Switch.
At the beginning of the first episode Ian was ruminating on lessons learned during his travels, and by the end of this one I had no idea why this particular escapade taught him what he said it did. Which was quite disappointing.
And that's quite enough for now.
Rating:
3/10. Though to be honest, weeks later, I'm surprised it's not lower - there must have been something more I enjoyed that I've forgotten!
Next Time:
Companion Chronicle 6.10, The Wanderer, as a whole.
First, then, to tie up a couple of loose ends from last time. I was right about Grigori, which tends to make me feel good unless it's meant to be a mystery and is too obvious, which isn't true in this case. That's a plus. However, I also said that - as the first pseudohistorical drama I've covered - this needed to have a good alien plot. This one is bog-standard.
(An aside: I have reviewed a Hartnell pseudohistorical in this marathon, but it was a short story. For some reason I hold those to a different standard.)
The alien plot, as I say, is generic, and this puts pressure on the aliens themselves to provide interest. They threaten, they bluster, they kill... and that's it. No real character tics that we haven't seen many times before. They are admittedly visually impressive (and wouldn't have worked at all on TV, which isn't a complaint), but this is not enough. And the final solution to combating the menace is all rather "wha? where did that come from?", bringing up thoughts about how geology doesn't work like that - an inappropriate complaint for a Doctor Who story, but the fact that it came up is a red flag. Basically, this part of the episode falls very flat - and it is the main part.
What about the rest of the story? In terms of action it felt like running back and forth between the same two places, so not much to work with there. The business with Grigori is handled okay - Tim Chipping's performance is suitably mad, and the resolution was quite coolly crazy (in a 1964-ish way) - but the manner in which the potential opportunity to return Iananbarbara home was short-circuited felt clumsy. It wasn't even really necessary to hold out this promise in the first place! Grigori's situation could have been resolved by judicious use of the Fast Return Switch.
At the beginning of the first episode Ian was ruminating on lessons learned during his travels, and by the end of this one I had no idea why this particular escapade taught him what he said it did. Which was quite disappointing.
And that's quite enough for now.
Rating:
3/10. Though to be honest, weeks later, I'm surprised it's not lower - there must have been something more I enjoyed that I've forgotten!
Next Time:
Companion Chronicle 6.10, The Wanderer, as a whole.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)