We've met John Dorney before in this marathon, wearing his actor hat in The Fragile Yellow Arc of Fragrance and Farewell, Great Macedon!;
but this is the first time we've hit one of the stories he's written.
He is actually the author of my favourite Companion Chronicle, Solitaire;
though as a full-cast two-hander I always feel that hardly counts, so
he may have to console himself with the fact that it's also one of only
eight 10/10 audios I've heard so far (out of about 200).
This one, though not quite up there, is still very good; and again the
production suits the script. As long-time readers will know I'm a bit of
a William Russell fan, and he's on good form here. There's a lot of
emotion in his reading, which is appropriate to the underlying theme of
the story as well as the action-packed nature of the narrative. Gus
Brown as Ashman is a well-chosen foil, suitably nasty and with a
distinct voice. I am renewing my determination to find out what an audio
director actually does beyond the obvious, but the prolific Lisa
Bowerman certainly gets a lot right - and congrats on the recent Benny
anniversary, Ms. Bowerman! The sound design is excellent, modern yet
appropriate to the story. If it had tried to match the style of the
Republic serials where the rocket men originated I think it would have
spoiled the mood.
Ah yes, the Republic serials. I've not seen King of the Rocket Men or its sequels, but I have seen the Disney film The Rocketeer,
adapted from the comic of the same name (which is almost a tribute to
the serials). The clever thing Dorney has done is to take all the pulpy
trappings of the original, place it in a Golden Age SF setting - and
then treat it completely seriously. This is not a pastiche, despite what
a summary of the plot might indicate, and it's all the more original
for that.
This is also one of the releases with an 'extra' - in this case an
interview with the author, which was great for finding out how he went
about writing it. Learning of the missing framing sequence (set after
Barbara's death) and how this wouldn't fly with Cardiff was enlightening
- I can see how it would have worked with this story, but to be honest
it isn't needed anyway. I was also happy to find that he didn't have a
story until he had the emotional hook, since this is something I often
find myself; and to learn of his love for the experimental nature of
this period of the show (in particular The Web Planet, which I hope I have boosted a little in my recent reviews).
Changing Formats
I liked the cover of this one - but since I only own it as a download I
don't get to see it that often, or in a particularly high resolution. As
I'm writing this it's the last day of the digital switchover for
television in the UK. A couple of weeks ago some friends who were
upgrading to a touch-screen edition of the Kindle gave us their old one,
so we now have another electronic entertainment device to fight over.
Technology rolls on.
Meanwhile, in our house, we don't have unlimited space (though it's
still much bigger than the house I grew up in). Because of the way my
mind works, one of the ways I tackle this is by being as ruthlessly
organised as my health and family will allow; and one of the areas this
has worked best is in collecting together all our audiovisual stuff. We
have two alcoves in the lounge, either side of the fireplace, and have
allocated the largest to this purpose. It houses the equipment (TV,
hifi, Isaac's Gamecube, a few odds and ends); a small number of
cassettes, videos, and LPs; and a large number of discs. All of my Doctor Who
material is now in two huge cases (holding over 500 discs each), with
the inlays, in chronological order from the Doctor's viewpoint. But
there is also an increasing number of stories that I only own in digital
format (the most recent being Voyage to Venus), and this change loses something that previous format changes haven't: the physical cover or inlay.
Some of my friends bemoaned the move to CD because they loved the
physicality of vinyl. I didn't feel the same, but was sad to see the
large record sleeves go. In fact, one of the few LPs I've kept - Anthony
Phillips' Private Parts and Pieces II, Back to the Pavilion - I
also have on CD, and I retain the original purely for the cover, by the
wonderful Peter Cross. These things matter to me. Not as much as the
actual content, but they matter.
I mention this because I have realised that the ideal Big Finish story
combination for me would be download-only audio plus full booklet. If
they started including a (printable-quality) PDF of the booklet with the
download, I would be a happy man.
And our cupboard space would thank them too.
Published:
Date: August 2011
ISBN: 1-84435-581-5
Rating:
7.5/10.
Next Time:
Some more of my own fiction, for once being posted in its correct
chronological position. This is probably going to be a two-part story;
it's designed to go just before The Crusade, and I'll be
releasing it in short chunks (about a page at a time). So join me for
the first scene of the first episode, which is titled Dialogue Disasters (in honour of Cornell, Day and Topping's Discontinuity Guide) - although it may be a while before the reason becomes clear...
John Dorney was kind enough to explain some more of his writing processes in a PM, and I thought other people might be interested too. So, quoting with his permission:
ReplyDelete[...] there was a vague justification in my mind for the second voice (I can't recall if I mentioned this in the extras). I vaguely structured it as a four parter where episode three was the only one that existed. So we hear the soundtrack for the third episode (the Ian/Ashman stuff) and the rest is narrated. In the present tense sequences, Ian doesn't do voices for any other characters (any Barbara/Vicki dialogue is reported speech, rather than voiced dialogue) and this is also why Ashman's dialogue is spoken by Ian in the past tense sequences (because that bit of the soundtrack doesn't exist!).
I will certainly bear this in mind when I listen to it again, and since I'll be commenting on William Russell's connecting pieces when I review The Crusade, I'll try to do so before then.